Peer review 2 of article Rick S. by Claudia N.
Appendix 3B – Weblog article peer review form
Weblog Article Peer Review Form B – Second Review
Writer’s Name _Rick Slaathuis______________________________________
Assessor’s name _Claudia Nieweg______________________________________
Date _09-10-07______________________________________
Rating Scale: 1 = Yes 2 = Somewhat 3 = No
Rate the article by giving a 1, 2 or 3 for each question. Read the article once to geta general idea of what it is about, then read it a second time to rate it.
1. Is the topic interesting? _1___
2. Is the title original and appropriate? _1___
3. Is the introduction complete? 1____
4. Is the body of your article complete? _1___
5. Is the conclusion well-developed? _1___
6. Is the article well-organized overall? 1____
7. Is the article easy to understand? _1___
8. Is the article interesting to read? 1____
9. Has any plagiarised material been removed? _1___
Do you feel that the writer has improved the article? Why or why not? Be specific.
Yes very much. There is a body in the text and the story is well organized with introduction and conclusion. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Has the writer changed the article adequately according to your suggestions forimprovement of your first assessment? Describe the changes and state specifically whether you think they are an improvement.
Yes, there is a body and he used more words. You can see that he spend more time on this article then the first article._______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Are you happy to have this article on your weblog? Why or why not? Be specific.
Yes because it’s an interesting article to read. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Give the writer this completed form.
