Peer review of Article Claudia. N by Kimberly V.
Weblog article peer review form
Weblog Article Peer Review Form A – First Review
Writer’s Name Claudia Nieweg da Silva Marcos_______________________________________
Assessor’s name Kimberly Vegting_______________________________________
Date 24-09-2007_______________________________________
Rating Scale: 1 = Yes 2 = Somewhat 3 = No
Rate the article by giving a 1, 2 or 3 for each question. Read the article once to geta general idea of what it is about, then read it a second time to rate it.
1. Is the topic interesting? 1____
2. Is the title original and appropriate? 2____
3. Is the introduction complete? 1____
4. Is the body of the article complete? 1____
5. Is the conclusion well-developed? 2____
6. Is the article well-organized overall? 2____
7. Is the article easy to understand? 1____
8. Is the article interesting to read? 1____
9. Has the writer plagiarised material? 3____
Finally, read the article a third time and check it for spelling, grammar andpunctuation. Mark any corrections on the article itself then complete the rest ofthe form.
Name three things you like about the article. It’s interesting, easy to read and useful for he O’Neill campaign. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Name three things the writer should improve. Punctiuation, more use of the word ‘and’, some spelling mistakes should be corrected.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
What is the gist of the article? Sms Alerts are a new way to make a better connection and service to your customers.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Do you think this article is good enough to pass the course? Explain your answer. Yes because it is a good article, easy to read and interesting. _______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Givet he writer this completed form and the article with corrections.
